科研 Skill

工程材料选型设计

materials-selection-design

Selects engineering materials via material indices and Ashby charts, ranking candidates by performance per cost or mass. Use when picking a material class for a design constraint.

发布者 Codar安全审核通过v0.1.0更新于 2026-11-18

SKILL.md

Materials Selection and Design

Purpose

Turn an engineering design requirement (a beam that must not fail under bending, a heat exchanger wall, a lightweight pressure vessel) into a short, ranked list of candidate materials, using the Ashby material-selection method: translate function, objective, and constraints into a material index, then screen a materials universe against that index on log-log property charts. This skill is the systematic bridge between "what does the part need to do" and "which material class should a downstream simulation or characterization skill investigate further" — it does not run DFT, MD, or mechanical tests itself.

When to Use This Skill

Activate when the request involves:

  • Choosing between material classes or specific alloys/polymers/ceramics/composites for a part subject to a structural, thermal, or electrical constraint.
  • "Minimize mass/cost for a given stiffness/strength," "select a material for X," "which material class should I simulate/test next."
  • Building or reading an Ashby chart (e.g., Young's modulus vs. density, strength vs. density) and computing where a material index line falls on it.
  • Comparing material indices across candidate classes to shortlist 3-5 options before committing to expensive DFT, MD, or experimental characterization.

Do not use this skill to perform the downstream physics: once a material class is selected, hand off to computational-materials, finite-element-modeling, mechanical-testing, or similar skills in this plugin to validate the choice.

Core Method: Function, Objective, Constraint, Free Variable

Every selection problem is decomposed into four elements before any chart is drawn:

  1. Function — what the component does (tie, beam, panel, shaft, pressure vessel, heat exchanger, electrical conductor, spring).
  2. Objective — what to minimize or maximize (mass, cost, volume, energy, or a combination such as cost per unit stiffness).
  3. Constraints — fixed requirements that must be satisfied (must support load F without failing, must not exceed deflection delta, must survive temperature T, must be electrically insulating, must be machinable).
  4. Free variables — what the designer can still choose (cross-sectional dimensions, material).

The key step is substituting the constraint equation into the objective equation to separate variables that depend on geometry from variables that depend only on material. The material-only part is the material index (sometimes called a material performance index), written M.

Deriving a Material Index (Worked Pattern)

For a light, stiff tie-rod of fixed length L under axial load F, with target deflection-free (fully stiff) behavior and free cross-section A:

  • Objective: minimize mass, m = A * L * rho
  • Constraint: stiffness S = F/delta = A * E / L (rearrange for A)
  • Substitute: m = (S * L^2 / E) * rho = S * L^2 * (rho / E)

Mass is minimized by minimizing rho/E, i.e. by maximizing E/rho. The material index for this case is:

M = E / rho          (stiffness-limited tie, minimize mass)

The same procedure for common cases:

Component / ConstraintObjectiveMaterial index M (maximize)
Tie, stiffness-limitedminimize massE / rho
Tie, strength-limitedminimize masssigma_y / rho
Beam, stiffness-limited (fixed section shape)minimize massE^(1/2) / rho
Beam, strength-limitedminimize masssigma_y^(2/3) / rho
Panel, stiffness-limited (fixed width, free thickness)minimize massE^(1/3) / rho
Column, buckling-limitedminimize massE^(1/2) / rho
Spring, store max energy per massminimize masssigma_y^2 / (E * rho)
Thermal insulation, steady stateminimize mass for fixed heat loss1 / (lambda) with rho via thickness tradeoff
Electrical conductor, fixed resistanceminimize massrho_density / sigma_electrical
Minimize material cost instead of masssame as abovereplace rho with rho * Cm (cost per mass) in the denominator

Where E = Young's modulus, rho = density, sigma_y = yield strength, lambda = thermal conductivity, Cm = cost per unit mass. For beams and panels the index exponent depends on which dimension is free versus fixed — re-derive it if the geometry differs from "fixed length, free cross-section."

Reading and Building Ashby Charts

An Ashby chart plots one material property against another on log-log axes (e.g., Young's modulus E vs. density rho), with each material class (steels, Al alloys, Ti alloys, engineering polymers, technical ceramics, composites, foams, woods, elastomers) shown as a labeled bubble or envelope spanning its typical property range.

  1. Plot the two properties that appear in the candidate material indices.
  2. For an index of the form M = E^n / rho, a line of the form log(E) = n * log(rho) + n * log(M) is a selection line of slope n on the E-rho chart. Materials above/left of the line (depending on which direction is better) outperform those below it for that index.
  3. Slide the selection line across the chart; materials it touches last, in the direction of improving performance, are the best performers for that index, independent of the absolute scale of the design.
  4. Apply constraint boxes second: eliminate materials that fail a hard requirement (max service temperature, corrosion environment, electrical insulation, recyclability) before ranking by the index. A material with the best index that fails a hard constraint is not a candidate.

Reference material property ranges (order-of-magnitude, for sanity-checking a screen, not for final design) by class:

ClassE (GPa)rho (Mg/m^3)sigma_y (MPa)Typical max service T (C)
Steels190-2107.5-8.0200-2000400-650
Al alloys68-822.6-2.950-600150-250
Ti alloys80-1304.3-4.8300-1200300-550
Ni superalloys190-2208.0-9.0600-1200900-1100
Engineering polymers1-40.9-1.520-10060-150
Technical ceramics (Al2O3, SiC)300-4503.0-3.9n/a (brittle; use fracture strength)1000-1600
CFRP (unidirectional)70-200 (fiber direction)1.5-1.6600-1800 (tensile, fiber direction)120-180 (matrix-limited)
Metal/polymer foams0.001-10.02-0.60.1-20class-dependent

These are illustrative midpoints; always pull current numbers from a materials property database (see materials-databases, materials-databases-access) or a vetted handbook (ASM Handbooks, MatWeb, Granta/CES Selector data) before finalizing a selection — this skill's tables are for first-pass screening only.

Multi-Objective and Penalty-Function Ranking

When mass and cost (or mass and another property) must be minimized together and no single index dominates:

  1. Normalize each candidate's performance on every objective to a 0-1 scale relative to the best and worst candidate in the shortlist.
  2. Combine with a weighted penalty function Z = sum(w_i * normalized_value_i), choosing weights w_i by stakeholder priority (this step is inherently subjective — document the weights used).
  3. Alternatively, compute a trade-off (Pareto) surface in the two objectives and present the non-dominated set rather than collapsing to one weighted score; this avoids hiding the trade-off from the decision-maker. For automated multi-objective search once a numeric model exists, see bayesian-optimization.

Shape Factors (When Section Shape Is a Free Variable)

If the cross-sectional shape (I-beam, tube, box) is also a design variable rather than fixed, a shape factor phi multiplies the material index to capture how much stiffness or strength a given material can gain from efficient shaping (e.g., a thin-walled tube is far stiffer per unit mass than a solid rod of the same material). Shape factors are material-class dependent (metals can be extruded or machined into efficient open/closed sections; ceramics are limited to simple convex shapes to avoid stress concentrations in manufacturing). When shape is free, compare M * phi across classes rather than M alone, and verify the assumed shape is actually manufacturable in that material class.

Prerequisites

  • The design requirement must already be reduced to a function, an objective, and at least one constraint; this skill does not perform structural analysis to derive loads or deflection limits (use finite-element-modeling or fem-multiphysics for that upstream step if loads are not already known).
  • Reasonably current material property data for the candidate universe — this skill's property table is illustrative only and must not be used for a final, safety-relevant decision.

Limitations

  • Ashby selection identifies promising material classes/indices, not a specific qualified alloy, heat treatment, or supplier grade; a final choice still requires specification-level data (e.g., an aerospace material spec sheet) and, for safety-critical parts, testing per mechanical-testing or fatigue-analysis-workflow. Fully ceramics and other brittle materials have no single "strength" — treat catalog sigma_y for ceramics as flexural/fracture strength to be revisited with the fracture-mechanics-workflow and materials-stats (Weibull) skills.
  • Material indices above assume elastic, linear, isotropic behavior; anisotropic materials (composites, single-crystal or textured metals) need directional property values, not the single scalar E/sigma_y shown in generic handbook ranges.
  • Cost data is volatile (commodity price swings, region-specific supply chains) and is not tracked by this skill; treat any embedded cost figures as placeholders.
  • Does not account for manufacturability, joining, or supply-chain constraints beyond simple constraint-box screening; these frequently eliminate an index-optimal material in practice.

Quality Checks

  • The derived material index matches the stated objective and constraint (re-derive by substitution rather than pattern-matching to the table when the geometry differs from the standard cases above).
  • Every shortlisted material satisfies all hard constraints (temperature, environment, electrical/magnetic behavior), not just the ranked index.
  • Property values used for the final ranking are sourced from a specific database or handbook entry (with units and temperature noted), not from this skill's illustrative table.
  • For brittle or anisotropic candidates, flag explicitly that scalar yield-strength comparisons are not directly meaningful and that downstream validation is needed.

示例提示词

帮我用Ashby材料选型法为这个承重结构件筛选出几种候选材料。

所属插件

材料表征、性能与材料信息学面向实验与数据驱动的材料研究:XRD/电镜/谱学/热分析/力学测试等表征,合成与加工,电化学与半导体表征,相场、CALPHAD 与连续介质力学,材料数据库、特征工程、贝叶斯优化与主动学习,选材与生命周期评价。

安装该插件会一并获得同领域的 42 个 Skill / MCP。

同插件的其他科研 Skill

常见问题

工程材料选型设计能做什么?

Selects engineering materials via material indices and Ashby charts, ranking candidates by performance per cost or mass. Use when picking a material class for a design constraint。

如何安装工程材料选型设计?

在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「工程材料选型设计」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。

工程材料选型设计需要哪些权限?

该科研 Skill没有声明额外权限;执行具体操作时仍由 Agent 按自身规则请求确认。

工程材料选型设计经过官方审核吗?

是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。