科研 Skill
科研导师式反馈
research-mentor-review
Gives constructive, evidence-based mentoring feedback on student manuscripts, proposals, code, and figures without impersonating an advisor. Use for advisor-style review of student work.
SKILL.md
Research Mentor Review
Purpose
Give the kind of feedback that helps a researcher improve independently: specific, prioritized, explainable, and tied to evidence, logic, and next actions. This is a mentoring workflow, not an impersonation of any advisor and not a substitute for authorship, supervisory judgment, or safety review.
Review Workflow
- Identify the deliverable, audience, decision it must support, available evidence, and the research stage.
- Start with what the work currently establishes and what remains unsupported.
- Review the highest-risk issues first: research question, novelty/gap logic, methods, assumptions, evidence quality, analysis, physical interpretation, and claim strength.
- Then address communication: paragraph/slide logic, citation practice, figures, tables, reproducibility, code, and presentation clarity.
- Convert each important critique into an actionable revision, validation, or question. Explain why it matters.
Feedback Standard
Separate:
- Required before a claim is defensible: missing evidence, invalid method, unsupported inference, citation issue, or reproducibility blocker.
- Recommended for clarity or impact: organization, figure design, concise wording, stronger comparison, or an additional sensitivity analysis.
- Questions for the author/advisor: scope, scientific priority, coauthor decision, target venue, resource commitment, or ethics and safety judgment.
Avoid generic praise, vague requests to "add detail," and invented literature or data. Quote or identify the exact location when possible. Keep the tone direct but respectful; explain the path forward rather than simply rejecting the work.
Formulaic Writing Check
When reviewing a manuscript or proposal, flag prose that reads as automatically assembled rather than technically chosen: detail-heavy abstracts, contrast words without a true contrast, unfamiliar or undefined labels, repeated vague forms of enable and establish, unusually, together, stacked hyphenated modifiers, catalog-like headings, modifier-heavy sentences, and inappropriate dash clauses. Describe the reader-facing problem and propose a specific revision. Do not infer or allege AI authorship from style alone.
Coordination
Use thermal-fluid-analysis for mechanics and heat-transfer judgment; research-writing-literature for narrative and citation work; research-data-analysis for DOE, code, data, and plots; research-slide-design for talks; research-schematic-design for facility, mechanism, workflow, and graphical-abstract figures; research-proposal-development for proposals; and reviewer-author-loop when the user wants repeated review, revision, and verification.
示例提示词
帮我以导师视角点评这篇学生论文的实验设计和结果呈现。
所属插件
安装该插件会一并获得同领域的 17 个 Skill / MCP。
同插件的其他科研 Skill
- 控制系统分析与PID设计Models, analyzes, and designs feedback control systems with python-control and scipy.signal: transfer functions, Bode plots, root locus, and PID tuning. Use for SISO control design.
- FEniCSx有限元分析Runs FEA with FEniCSx or scikit-fem: mesh generation, boundary conditions, linear elasticity, heat conduction, and result visualization. Use for custom open-source finite-element workflows.
- 测量不确定度分析Builds a GUM-style measurement uncertainty budget from Type A/B evaluation, RSS combination, and error propagation to a derived result. Use when a reported value needs a defensible plus-or-minus.
- 热流体系统研究方法指导Applies source-aware mechanical-engineering judgment to research tasks spanning thermal-fluids, turbomachinery, experiments, and writing. Use for broad mechanical-engineering research support.
- 可靠性工程分析Covers reliability engineering methods: Weibull analysis, fault tree analysis, FMEA, reliability block diagrams, and accelerated life testing. Use for failure-rate or reliability-prediction tasks.
- 工程实验数据分析设计Designs and analyzes engineering experiments or simulations with baseline cases, hypothesis-driven DOE, and uncertainty quantification. Use for CFD, lab data, or parameter-study analysis.
- 研究计划书撰写Develops research proposals with solicitation alignment, reviewer-focused logic, evidence-bounded preliminary results, and milestones. Use for federal, foundation, or internal research proposals.
- 科研示意图制作Creates publication-quality, editable scientific and engineering schematics with explicit physical meaning and clear labels. Use for experimental-facility diagrams, mechanisms, or graphical abstracts.
- 科研汇报幻灯片设计Designs clean, graphics-first technical presentations and posters with logical progression and visual hierarchy. Use for research talks, conference slides, or defenses.
- 科研写作与文献综述Writes and revises research narratives, literature reviews, manuscript sections, and figure discussions with proper citations. Use for drafting or revising technical manuscript text.
- 审稿人作者迭代改稿Runs an iterative manuscript-improvement loop where a reviewer agent critiques, an author agent revises, and a verifier checks each revision. Use for simulated peer review or rebuttal prep.
- ROS2机器人开发Covers ROS2 robotics development with rclpy: nodes, topics, services, actions, tf2 transforms, and Nav2 navigation. Use when building or debugging a ROS2 node or navigation stack.
- 数字信号处理Covers digital signal processing with scipy.signal: filter design, spectral analysis, peak detection, and PSD estimation. Use for vibration, biomedical, or time-series signal tasks.
- SimPy离散事件仿真Builds discrete-event simulations with SimPy: M/M/c queues, manufacturing lines, resource contention, and confidence intervals via replications. Use for queueing or throughput analysis.
- 热流体系统分析指导Analyzes thermal-fluid systems, experiments, CFD, and correlations with explicit assumptions, validity limits, and uncertainty. Use for heat transfer or thermal-management analysis.
- 机械振动与故障诊断Analyzes mechanical vibration: SDOF/MDOF natural frequencies, resonance checks, and FFT-based diagnosis of rotating-machinery faults such as imbalance or bearing defects. Use for vibration diagnosis.
常见问题
科研导师式反馈能做什么?
Gives constructive, evidence-based mentoring feedback on student manuscripts, proposals, code, and figures without impersonating an advisor. Use for advisor-style review of student work。
如何安装科研导师式反馈?
在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「科研导师式反馈」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。
科研导师式反馈需要哪些权限?
该科研 Skill没有声明额外权限;执行具体操作时仍由 Agent 按自身规则请求确认。
科研导师式反馈经过官方审核吗?
是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。