科研 Skill
食品论文多审稿人模拟
food-review
Simulates an editorial peer-review panel for a food/nutrition manuscript, grounded in cited and field literature first. Use for a pre-submission review or mock referee report.
SKILL.md
Food-Review — Multi-Reviewer Peer Review for Food & Nutrition Manuscripts
Give the author the review a good food-science journal would return, from a panel rather than a single voice. Original work; architecture informed by open community peer-review skills (see the repo README Acknowledgements).
Modes
- full (default) — the whole panel: three domain reviewers + devil's advocate + format check, synthesized by the coordinator into an editorial decision.
- quick — coordinator + one blended reviewer pass; a fast readiness verdict.
- methodology — deep dive by
reviewer_methodologyonly. - re-review — re-assess a revised manuscript against the prior reports and the author's response, verifying each point was addressed.
Panel (dispatch via the Agent tool; reviewers run in parallel)
review_coordinator(editor-in-chief) — sets the target journal + scope, dispatchesknowledge_builder, then the reviewers, synthesizes their reports, resolves disagreement, and issues the decision.knowledge_builder— runs first: reads the manuscript's cited sources (Pathway A) and the field's key literature (Pathway B) into a shared knowledge base so the panel judges the science from knowledge, not impression.reviewer_methodology— design, statistics, reproducibility, validation.reviewer_domain— novelty, significance, scope fit, domain correctness (food/nutrition science).reviewer_integrity— data & citation integrity, food-safety/ethics, reporting completeness.devils_advocate— adversarial challenge to the paper's central claim.format_checker— formatting & reference-style compliance vs the target journal.
Ground the panel first — the knowledge base
Reviewers must understand the topic and its background before they critique it.
knowledge_builder runs before the reviewers and builds one knowledge base from:
- A — the manuscript's own citations: retrieve and read the full cited articles, extract what each actually shows, and audit whether it supports the claim it is attached to.
- B — the field's key literature: extract the manuscript's keywords and
research disciplines, search the literature for the field's key work
(may use the
food-researchfull reviewbranch for discovery/screening — but knowledge extraction only, no literature-review article).
A + B give the panel the state of the art, standard methods and benchmark values, consensus vs contested points, a novelty map, and gaps — so novelty and correctness are judged, not guessed. Never summarize a source that was not retrieved; mark abstract-only and unretrievable items. In quick mode, build a light version (Pathway A spot-checks on the load-bearing citations).
Inside food-pipeline (Stage 1 already ran): don't search the field twice —
reuse the Stage-1 evidence base in place of the Pathway-B search, topped up with
food-research quick brief to find the field's key review publications and
read them in full; knowledge base = Stage-1 knowledge + key-review knowledge
(Pathway A still runs). Standalone food-review is unaffected and always builds
the full A + B.
Workflow
flowchart TD
A[Manuscript in] --> B[review_coordinator<br/>resolve target journal + scope]
B --> JS[journal-selector<br/>ask once → journal or 'generic'/APA 7.0]
B --> KB[knowledge_builder<br/>A: read cited sources<br/>B: key field literature]
KB --> KBase[(Knowledge base<br/>state of the art · benchmarks ·<br/>novelty map · cited-source audit)]
KBase --> R1[reviewer_methodology]
KBase --> R2[reviewer_domain]
KBase --> R3[reviewer_integrity]
KBase --> R4[devils_advocate]
JS --> FC[format_checker]
R1 --> C[review_coordinator<br/>synthesize + decision]
R2 --> C
R3 --> C
R4 --> C
FC --> C
C --> O[Panel report:<br/>per-reviewer reports + format check +<br/>editorial decision + revision checklist +<br/>response-letter skeleton]
Formatting / target journal
The review_coordinator first establishes the target journal by calling
journal-selector/SKILL.md (a shared procedure, not an installed skill), which
asks the user which journal the manuscript targets
(they may answer 'generic' → APA 7.0). This is asked once: the resolved
journal's structure, limits, and reference/citation style are recorded and reused,
and format_checker audits the manuscript against them. Don't re-ask unless the
user names a different target journal; reuse the choice if food-pipeline already
resolved one.
Output — a Word (.docx) report, not Markdown
A consolidated review report delivered as a .docx in the canonical structure of
references/report-format.md: header (manuscript, target journal, editorial
decision, colour legend) → overall assessment → Part A editing report by
category → summary → Part B scientific-quality comments + editorial decision +
residual items → Part C figure/table consistency audit. Every concern carries a
stable issue ID (A#/B#/C#/D#, SQ#, FC#) and a Response (<type>) line —
Recommendation or, for a fix that needs the author's data/decision, Editor
query — with a precise location (P## / Table / Figure). Critique the work, not
the author.
Markdown is a working format, never the deliverable. Convert with Pandoc
(pandoc report.md -o report.docx) or the docx skill; if neither is
available, say so and hand over the Markdown with the conversion command — never
claim a .docx you did not produce. Apply the colour legend as real Word formatting
and leave no Markdown syntax in the file. Inside food-pipeline this report is the
single document that food-paper later fills responses into — no separate response
letter is created (see references/report-format.md).
When the manuscript is a Word (.docx) file (or equivalent — LibreOffice /
Pages / Google Docs), also deliver the manuscript itself with margin comments.
In addition to the report, insert the panel's concerns as Word review comments
anchored to the exact text they target (one comment per concern, prefixed with the
reviewer lens + severity), using the word processor's Review/Comments feature. See
references/word-review-comments.md. If the manuscript isn't a Word doc or no Word
tooling is available, deliver a location→comment table instead and say so.
References (load as needed)
references/report-format.md— canonical review report + revision-log format (Parts A/B/C, issue IDs,Response (<type>)taxonomy, editor queries, colour legend).references/review-criteria.md— what each reviewer checks (food-tuned).references/quality-rubrics.md— 1–5 scoring per dimension + weights.references/editorial-decisions.md—review_coordinator: Accept/Minor/Major/Reject logic + overrides.references/word-review-comments.md— insert margin comments into a Word/.docxmanuscript (in addition to the report).references/ethics-integrity-checklist.md—reviewer_integrity(canonical; shared withfood-deep-research).food-paper/references/statistics-reporting.md—reviewer_methodology: stats red flags.food-paper/references/faithfulness-and-citation.md—reviewer_integrity: verify every citation is real (four-gate) and every claim is source-bound; flag any fabricated/unsupported content.food-research/references/full-text-access.md—knowledge_builder: how to actually read the cited papers (open access → connected tool → user-supplied PDFs → library session), when to ask the author for access, and how to report what a paywall blocked.food-paper/references/privacy-and-confidentiality.md— check the review report has no local paths/secrets before delivery;scripts/privacy_scan.py.
Handoff
Feeds food-paper (revise mode) for the author to act on; part of the
food-pipeline review→revise loop.
示例提示词
帮我模拟编辑部对这篇食品科学稿件做方法学和伦理审查评议。
所属插件
安装该插件会一并获得同领域的 20 个 Skill / MCP。
同插件的其他科研 Skill
- 农业深度研究综述Deep research producing a source-validated literature review for an agricultural question, ranked by journal quartile. Reuses food-deep-research machinery. Use for an agronomy deep dive.
- 农业科学论文撰写系统Multi-subagent manuscript system for agricultural science with field-trial/soil/animal reporting standards. Reuses food-paper machinery. Use for an agronomy or soil-science manuscript.
- 农业研究全流程编排Orchestrates the full agricultural research-to-publication workflow: journal selection, research, writing, figures, peer review, revision. Use to manage an agronomy project end to end.
- 农业综述转可编辑PPTConverts an agricultural-science report or manuscript into a fully editable PowerPoint deck, reusing food-ppt machinery with agronomy framing. Use for slides from a field-trial report.
- 农业遥感作物制图Maps crop types from Sentinel-2 imagery with Random Forest, extracts NDVI phenology, estimates LAI, and predicts yield via Google Earth Engine. Use for field/county crop remote sensing.
- 农业文献证据综合Multi-source literature and evidence-synthesis workflow for agricultural science, ranked by journal quartile. Reuses food-research machinery. Use for an agronomy or soil-science evidence review.
- 农业论文多审稿人模拟Simulates an editorial peer-review panel for an agricultural manuscript, grounded in cited and field literature. Use for a pre-submission review or mock referee report in agriculture.
- 作物生长模拟Simulates crop growth with WOFOST/AquaCrop via PCSE, pulls weather from NASA POWER, and runs yield-gap analysis under climate scenarios. Use for agronomic intervention evidence.
- 田间试验混合模型分析Analyzes RCBD, split-plot, and multi-site field-trial data with mixed models in R (lme4) or Python (statsmodels), using correct error strata. Use for a crop or soil field-trial analysis.
- 通用深度文献综述研究General-purpose deep research producing a source-validated, fully written literature review via a 12-subagent team. Use for a thorough review or deep-dive needing verified sources.
- 学术文献全文合法获取Lawfully acquires full-text PDFs via open access, the user’s reference manager, or their logged-in library session; never bypasses paywalls. Use to fetch papers before research or review.
- 食品营养论文图表系统Builds publication-ready figures (bar/box, dose-response, PCA, heatmaps, forest plots) to a target journal’s spec, with a privacy scan before delivery. Use for a journal-ready figure.
- 食品科学论文撰写系统Multi-subagent manuscript system for food/nutrition science: frames questions, analyzes data, writes statistics, drafts, polishes, and reformats for a journal. Use to write or revise a paper.
- 食品研究全流程编排Orchestrates the whole food/nutrition research-to-publication workflow with quality gates: journal selection, research, writing, figures, review, revision. Use to manage a paper end to end.
- 食品研究报告转可编辑PPTConverts a food/agriculture report or manuscript into a fully editable PowerPoint deck with python-pptx: outline, grounded slide text, themed layout. Use to make slides from a paper.
- 科研基金申请书编排Orchestrates a food/agriculture funding proposal to a scheme’s format (headings, length limit, criteria), drafting or revising via the research/paper/review skills. Use for a grant application.
- 食品营养文献综合研究Runs a multi-source literature and evidence-synthesis workflow for food/nutrition science: search, two-phase screening, synthesis, evidence grading. Use for a deep review or systematic-review scope.
- FAOSTAT食品系统数据分析Analyzes FAOSTAT food-balance, dietary-diversity, and trade/production data for cross-country food-systems indicators. Use for a country-comparison food-security dataset.
- 土壤数据空间分析Pulls and analyzes soil properties from SoilGrids (global) and SSURGO (US-only), computes SOC stock, and runs kriging interpolation. Use for a soil-property or soil-carbon map.
常见问题
食品论文多审稿人模拟能做什么?
Simulates an editorial peer-review panel for a food/nutrition manuscript, grounded in cited and field literature first. Use for a pre-submission review or mock referee report。
如何安装食品论文多审稿人模拟?
在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「食品论文多审稿人模拟」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。
食品论文多审稿人模拟需要哪些权限?
该科研 Skill没有声明额外权限;执行具体操作时仍由 Agent 按自身规则请求确认。
食品论文多审稿人模拟经过官方审核吗?
是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。