科研 Skill
农业论文多审稿人模拟
agri-review
Simulates an editorial peer-review panel for an agricultural manuscript, grounded in cited and field literature. Use for a pre-submission review or mock referee report in agriculture.
SKILL.md
Agri-Review — Peer-Review Panel for Agricultural Science
Run the food-review skill exactly — its panel (review_coordinator,
knowledge_builder, reviewer_methodology, reviewer_domain,
reviewer_integrity, devils_advocate, format_checker), its modes (full ·
quick · methodology · re-review), and its report format — with the agriculture
substitutions in
agri-research/references/agriculture-domain.md.
Read that file first. No new machinery here.
The substitutions
- Persona — every reviewer is a senior agricultural scientist of the specific discipline (agronomy · soil science · horticulture · dairy & animal science · agricultural engineering · agricultural economics & policy). Name the discipline; a soil-carbon paper gets a soil scientist's standards (domain §2).
- Knowledge base —
knowledge_builderruns first, unchanged in method: Pathway A reads the manuscript's cited sources in full and audits whether each supports its claim; Pathway B reads the field's key literature, ranked as Tier 1 Q1/Q2 agriculture (journals/_coverage_agriculture.md)- Nature/Science/Cell/PNAS + Q1/Q2 adjacent disciplines, Q4 avoided. Pathway B
may use
agri-research'sfull reviewbranch for discovery/screening — knowledge extraction only, no literature-review article (domain §3). Insideagri-pipelinewith a Stage-1 evidence base: reuse it and top up withagri-researchquick brief key reviews, exactly asfood-reviewdoes.
- Nature/Science/Cell/PNAS + Q1/Q2 adjacent disciplines, Q4 avoided. Pathway B
may use
- Journal routing —
format_checkeraudits against the journal resolved once byjournal-selectorfrom the agriculture coverage map (domain §4); APA 7.0 default.
What an agricultural reviewer checks first (domain §5)
- The experimental unit / pseudoreplication — subsamples counted as replicates, plants scored as units within one plot, animals within one pen. The single most common fatal flaw; raise it as Critical when present.
- Field-trial reporting — site, season(s)/years, soil classification, cultivar, plot size, design, replication, management, statistical model.
- Generalisation — one site-year, one region, or a pot/glasshouse study presented as a general agronomic recommendation; missing G×E.
- Animal work — ethics approval and ARRIVE; diet composition; unit (pen vs animal).
- Soil work — sampling depth, bulk density, equivalent-soil-mass basis for stock claims.
- Economics/policy — identification strategy; causal language unearned by design.
Inherited unchanged (not optional)
The report format (food-review/references/report-format.md: Parts A/B/C, stable
issue IDs, Response (type) taxonomy, editorial decision — Accept · Minor
Revision · Major Revision · Reject with the decisive reasons) and its
Word (.docx) deliverable rule — never Markdown; inside agri-pipeline this is
the single Review & Response Report that agri-paper later fills responses into,
so no separate reviewer report or response letter is created. Also inherited:
editor-query comments placed in the manuscript for fixes needing the author's
data (word-review-comments.md), the AI-writing-tell check (human-writing.md), the
privacy scan, and the rule that a source never retrieved is marked, not
summarized.
示例提示词
帮我模拟编辑和三位领域审稿人对这篇农学稿件的评审意见。
所属插件
安装该插件会一并获得同领域的 20 个 Skill / MCP。
同插件的其他科研 Skill
- 农业深度研究综述Deep research producing a source-validated literature review for an agricultural question, ranked by journal quartile. Reuses food-deep-research machinery. Use for an agronomy deep dive.
- 农业科学论文撰写系统Multi-subagent manuscript system for agricultural science with field-trial/soil/animal reporting standards. Reuses food-paper machinery. Use for an agronomy or soil-science manuscript.
- 农业研究全流程编排Orchestrates the full agricultural research-to-publication workflow: journal selection, research, writing, figures, peer review, revision. Use to manage an agronomy project end to end.
- 农业综述转可编辑PPTConverts an agricultural-science report or manuscript into a fully editable PowerPoint deck, reusing food-ppt machinery with agronomy framing. Use for slides from a field-trial report.
- 农业遥感作物制图Maps crop types from Sentinel-2 imagery with Random Forest, extracts NDVI phenology, estimates LAI, and predicts yield via Google Earth Engine. Use for field/county crop remote sensing.
- 农业文献证据综合Multi-source literature and evidence-synthesis workflow for agricultural science, ranked by journal quartile. Reuses food-research machinery. Use for an agronomy or soil-science evidence review.
- 作物生长模拟Simulates crop growth with WOFOST/AquaCrop via PCSE, pulls weather from NASA POWER, and runs yield-gap analysis under climate scenarios. Use for agronomic intervention evidence.
- 田间试验混合模型分析Analyzes RCBD, split-plot, and multi-site field-trial data with mixed models in R (lme4) or Python (statsmodels), using correct error strata. Use for a crop or soil field-trial analysis.
- 通用深度文献综述研究General-purpose deep research producing a source-validated, fully written literature review via a 12-subagent team. Use for a thorough review or deep-dive needing verified sources.
- 学术文献全文合法获取Lawfully acquires full-text PDFs via open access, the user’s reference manager, or their logged-in library session; never bypasses paywalls. Use to fetch papers before research or review.
- 食品营养论文图表系统Builds publication-ready figures (bar/box, dose-response, PCA, heatmaps, forest plots) to a target journal’s spec, with a privacy scan before delivery. Use for a journal-ready figure.
- 食品科学论文撰写系统Multi-subagent manuscript system for food/nutrition science: frames questions, analyzes data, writes statistics, drafts, polishes, and reformats for a journal. Use to write or revise a paper.
- 食品研究全流程编排Orchestrates the whole food/nutrition research-to-publication workflow with quality gates: journal selection, research, writing, figures, review, revision. Use to manage a paper end to end.
- 食品研究报告转可编辑PPTConverts a food/agriculture report or manuscript into a fully editable PowerPoint deck with python-pptx: outline, grounded slide text, themed layout. Use to make slides from a paper.
- 科研基金申请书编排Orchestrates a food/agriculture funding proposal to a scheme’s format (headings, length limit, criteria), drafting or revising via the research/paper/review skills. Use for a grant application.
- 食品营养文献综合研究Runs a multi-source literature and evidence-synthesis workflow for food/nutrition science: search, two-phase screening, synthesis, evidence grading. Use for a deep review or systematic-review scope.
- 食品论文多审稿人模拟Simulates an editorial peer-review panel for a food/nutrition manuscript, grounded in cited and field literature first. Use for a pre-submission review or mock referee report.
- FAOSTAT食品系统数据分析Analyzes FAOSTAT food-balance, dietary-diversity, and trade/production data for cross-country food-systems indicators. Use for a country-comparison food-security dataset.
- 土壤数据空间分析Pulls and analyzes soil properties from SoilGrids (global) and SSURGO (US-only), computes SOC stock, and runs kriging interpolation. Use for a soil-property or soil-carbon map.
常见问题
农业论文多审稿人模拟能做什么?
Simulates an editorial peer-review panel for an agricultural manuscript, grounded in cited and field literature. Use for a pre-submission review or mock referee report in agriculture。
如何安装农业论文多审稿人模拟?
在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「农业论文多审稿人模拟」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。
农业论文多审稿人模拟需要哪些权限?
该科研 Skill没有声明额外权限;执行具体操作时仍由 Agent 按自身规则请求确认。
农业论文多审稿人模拟经过官方审核吗?
是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。