科研 Skill

文献计量分析

bibliometric-literature-analysis

Runs bibliometric and co-citation analysis for management or economics literature reviews using CiteSpace, VOSviewer, or bibliometrix. Use for citation-network mapping.

发布者 Codar安全审核通过v0.1.0更新于 2026-11-18

SKILL.md

Bibliometric and Citation-Network Literature Analysis

Purpose

Bibliometric analysis maps the structure of a research field quantitatively from publication and citation metadata: which papers, authors, journals, and keywords are most influential, how sub-fields cluster, and how the field has evolved over time. This complements, and precedes, the narrative/thematic literature review covered elsewhere in this marketplace (lit-review, mgmt-paper-writing's introduction-writing guidance) — bibliometrics tells you what the field looks like structurally (co-citation clusters, keyword co-occurrence, influential outlets) before you read and synthesize the content of the most relevant papers. Use it for management, economics, finance, or interdisciplinary literature reviews, grant-proposal "state of the field" sections, or to defend a journal/topic choice with objective citation evidence.

When to Use

Use when the request mentions:

  • bibliometric analysis, bibliometrics, citation analysis
  • co-citation network, bibliographic coupling, keyword co-occurrence
  • CiteSpace, VOSviewer, bibliometrix (R package), Bibliometrix web app
  • "map the field," "most influential papers/authors/journals in X"
  • systematic mapping of a research domain's intellectual structure

Do not use for:

  • the narrative synthesis and gap analysis of a systematic review itself (see lit-review for the search-strategy-to-synthesis workflow this skill feeds into)
  • single-paper reference management or citation formatting (mgmt-paper-writing covers GB/T 7714 citation style)
  • quantitative meta-analysis of effect sizes across studies (see alterlab-meta-analysis in the social-science plugin) — that pools statistical results, this pools citation/co-citation metadata

Core Workflow

Step 1 — Define Scope and Retrieve Metadata

  • State the search scope precisely: database(s) (Web of Science Core Collection, Scopus, or CNKI for Chinese-language literature — note that WoS/Scopus and CNKI have very different indexing and should not be silently merged), query string, date range, document type filters (article vs. review vs. conference), and language.
  • Export full metadata records (not just titles/abstracts) including cited references — co-citation and bibliographic-coupling analysis require the reference lists, which only WoS/Scopus/CNKI exports include, not a plain Google Scholar export.
  • Record the exact retrieval date and query string; bibliometric databases are updated continuously, so results are not exactly reproducible later without this record.

Step 2 — Choose the Analysis Type for the Research Question

QuestionMethodTypical tool
Which papers define the field's intellectual base?Co-citation analysis (papers cited together)CiteSpace, VOSviewer
Which recent papers are structurally similar?Bibliographic coupling (papers citing the same sources)CiteSpace, VOSviewer
What topics/keywords cluster and how have they evolved?Keyword co-occurrence + burst detectionCiteSpace
Which authors/institutions/countries lead the field?Co-authorship network, productivity countsVOSviewer, bibliometrix
Overall descriptive bibliometrics (growth, most-cited, h-index)Performance analysisbibliometrix (R), Bibliometrix app

Do not run every analysis type reflexively; pick the one(s) that answer the stated research question and justify the choice in the write-up.

Step 3 — Run the Network Analysis

  • VOSviewer: import the WoS/Scopus export directly; construct and visualize co-citation, bibliographic-coupling, or co-occurrence networks with density/overlay/cluster views. Good default for a clean, publication- ready network map with minimal configuration.
  • CiteSpace (Java-based, Chen Chaomei): best for citation-burst detection (which papers/keywords saw a sudden surge in attention — useful for identifying emerging sub-topics) and timeline/time-zone views showing the field's temporal evolution. Steeper learning curve than VOSviewer.
  • bibliometrix (R package) / its Biblioshiny web interface: best for reproducible, scriptable analysis (thematic maps, three-fields plots linking authors-keywords-sources, Lotka's law productivity analysis) and for generating publication tables (most-cited papers, most-productive authors) directly as R objects for a manuscript.

State the clustering algorithm and resolution/threshold parameters used (e.g., VOSviewer's association-strength normalization, minimum co-occurrence threshold) — cluster membership is sensitive to these choices and should be reported, not left as an undocumented default.

Step 4 — Interpret Clusters Qualitatively

A cluster is a set of papers that frequently co-cite or co-occur, not automatically a coherent "theme" — read the top papers in each cluster and label it substantively (e.g., "Cluster 2: real-options approaches to R&D investment") rather than reporting bare cluster numbers. Cross-check the label against keyword frequency within the cluster.

Step 5 — Report with Reproducibility Metadata

Report: database(s) and query string, retrieval date, inclusion/exclusion filters, document count at each filtering stage (a PRISMA-style flow is appropriate here too), software and version, and clustering parameters. Export the network visualization at publication resolution (vector PDF/SVG where the tool supports it) and provide the underlying count tables as an appendix for reviewers who want to verify a specific node's citation count.

Step 6 — Feed Forward into the Narrative Review

Use the bibliometric map to prioritize which papers get close reading in the narrative synthesis (central/high-citation nodes in the relevant cluster, plus recent burst papers signaling an emerging direction) — hand this prioritized reading list to lit-review for the thematic synthesis and gap analysis.

Prerequisites

  • Access to Web of Science, Scopus, or CNKI (institutional subscription typically required) to export metadata with full cited-reference lists; a plain Google Scholar or publisher-website search is insufficient for co-citation/coupling analysis.
  • VOSviewer (free, Java-based desktop app), CiteSpace (free, Java-based), or R with the bibliometrix package installed, depending on chosen method.
  • Enough familiarity with the field to substantively label clusters — the software produces numeric clusters; a domain expert must interpret them.

Limitations

  • Citation counts are strongly time-biased: recent papers have had less time to accumulate citations, which will understate their apparent importance relative to older papers — note publication-year effects explicitly rather than ranking purely by raw citation count.
  • Database coverage differs: WoS and Scopus under-index books, non-English journals, and some regional journals; CNKI covers Chinese-language venues WoS/Scopus largely miss. State which literature the chosen database(s) can and cannot see.
  • Clustering results are sensitive to the similarity measure and threshold chosen; report these parameters and treat cluster boundaries as interpretive aids, not ground truth.
  • This skill maps field structure; it does not itself assess the methodological quality or validity of the papers within a cluster — pair with a narrative review step for critical appraisal.

Quality Checklist

  • Database(s), query string, filters, and retrieval date recorded
  • Analysis type (co-citation / coupling / co-occurrence / performance) matched to the research question
  • Clustering/threshold parameters reported, not left as undocumented defaults
  • Every cluster substantively labeled and checked against its top papers, not just numbered
  • Publication-year citation bias acknowledged when ranking by citation count
  • Output feeds into a qualitative synthesis step rather than standing alone as the full review

示例提示词

帮我用VOSviewer做文献共被引分析,画出研究领域的知识图谱。

所属插件

经济金融与管理研究面向经济、金融与管理学研究:DID/IV/RDD/合成控制、面板与时间序列计量、事件研究与因子模型、期权与组合、管理学论文写作、NSFC 申请与质性/混合方法。

安装该插件会一并获得同领域的 40 个 Skill / MCP。

同插件的其他科研 Skill

常见问题

文献计量分析能做什么?

Runs bibliometric and co-citation analysis for management or economics literature reviews using CiteSpace, VOSviewer, or bibliometrix. Use for citation-network mapping。

如何安装文献计量分析?

在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「文献计量分析」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。

文献计量分析需要哪些权限?

该科研 Skill没有声明额外权限;执行具体操作时仍由 Agent 按自身规则请求确认。

文献计量分析经过官方审核吗?

是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。