科研 Skill
arXiv 投稿预检
arxiv-preflight
检查 arXiv 投稿前稿件风险
Skill 说明
arXiv 投稿前的稿件就绪度自检(假参考文献 / 残留 LLM 提示 / 占位数据 / AI 使用披露 / 科研诚信) | 输入:论文文件夹 | 输出:就绪度报告(假参考 / 残留 prompt / 数据占位 / AI 披露)
SKILL.md
arXiv Preflight
Submission-readiness review for a manuscript before arXiv upload. The goal is not to judge whether a paper was AI-written from style. The goal is to find concrete, locatable, reviewable evidence of unchecked LLM output, hallucinated references, placeholder data, unsupported claims, and arXiv-policy risks — and to hand the author a fix list.
Anchor on the actual arXiv stance: authors may use generative AI tools but are fully responsible for the content and must disclose significant use per field norms; AI tools cannot be listed as authors. See references/arxiv_policy_notes.md for the exact language.
This skill is intentionally platform-neutral. It should work for any AI coding/review agent that can read files and run local Python scripts; it does not require OpenAI-specific UI metadata.
Requires Python 3.9+.
Workflow
-
Identify inputs. Ask for or detect: LaTeX project directory, single PDF, BibTeX file, supplementary figures/tables, or experiment data. Prefer LaTeX source over rendered PDF — PDF text extraction loses structure and produces noisier reference checks.
-
Extract manuscript text. Run
scripts/extract_manuscript_text.pyon the input. It merges\input/\include, strips LaTeX commands while preserving section/figure/table/citation keys, and falls back to PDF text extraction. Output:manuscript.jsonwithsections,figures,tables,cite_keys,numbers, andwarnings. Treat unresolved or skipped includes as review risks. -
Hard-red-line scan. Run
scripts/scan_ai_artifacts.pyagainst the extracted text. It flags LLM meta-comments, prompt residue, placeholder content, TODO/TBD/XX%, and AI-listed-as-author. Patterns live inreferences/ai_artifact_patterns.md— extend the list when the user reports new failure modes. Any hit is aBLOCKERunless the user explicitly justifies it. -
Verify references. Run
scripts/verify_references.pyon.bib(or extracted reference list). It performs (a) structural BibTeX checks, (b) external metadata lookup against Crossref / arXiv / OpenAlex / Semantic Scholar (in that order), (c) cite-key vs. \cite reconciliation. Grading and API strategy:references/reference_verification.md. If network is unavailable, mark this sectionINCOMPLETErather than skipping silently. -
Cross-check claims, numbers, and figure/table references. Use
manuscript.jsonto review extracted numbers, labels, and references. This version exposes the raw structures for agent-assisted consistency review; it does not fully automate semantic claim verification. Surface candidate inconsistencies for the author to confirm, never rewrite their claims. -
AI-use disclosure check.
scripts/scan_ai_artifacts.pyincludes a limited disclosure heuristic for substantive LLM use. For nuanced cases, compare detected AI-assistance signals against the manuscript's Acknowledgments / Methods / Ethics sections yourself. Recommend disclosure only when significant use is evident; do not push boilerplate disclosure on every paper. Calibration:references/arxiv_policy_notes.md. -
arXiv moderation pre-check. Do an agent-assisted scan for non-research content (opinion/proposal/course-project framing without research contribution), copyright risks (publisher PDFs, reviewer comments, unlicensed images, long third-party text), and salami/duplicate-submission signals. This version does not ship a dedicated moderation scanner. Do not predict whether arXiv will accept — only surface risk.
-
Generate report. Run
scripts/generate_preflight_report.pyto merge all JSON outputs into a single Markdown report. Format and decision rules:references/report_template.md.
Risk levels
BLOCKER— evidence that should stop submission: LLM meta-comment in body text, AI listed as author, reference that cannot be matched in any external database, unfilled placeholder in a results table.HIGH— likely integrity or policy issue: DOI/title mismatch, cite-key pointing at wrong paper, a strong claim with no supporting number in the manuscript.MEDIUM— inconsistency, missing metadata, unclear disclosure, broken \ref.LOW— polish, formatting, capitalization.
Decision rule
- Any
BLOCKER→HOLD. - No blocker, any
HIGH/MEDIUM→PASS_WITH_FIXES. - Only
LOWor clean →PASS.
Never upgrade a finding's severity to be safe and never silently soften it. If you are unsure, mark it MEDIUM and explain.
Rules
- Never call a paper AI-generated from writing style alone. Style is not evidence; meta-comments, fake citations, and placeholders are.
- Every finding must cite a location. File + line number for
.tex/.bib; for PDF input, use the PDF file plus extracted-text line unless page-aware extraction is available. Include a verbatim short snippet (≤ 25 words). A finding without a location is a suggestion, not a finding — move it to "Recommended Cleanup". - Treat external-metadata mismatches as leads. A single field disagreement (e.g., page numbers) is
MEDIUM. Title + authors + year all unmatched across all four databases isBLOCKER. - Network-incomplete is not network-pass. If reference lookups failed for connectivity reasons, the report's reference section is
INCOMPLETE; the overall decision cannot bePASS. - Do not rewrite the author's claims. Provide fixes, questions, and locations. Leave the rewriting to the author.
- Minimise false positives at the cost of recall. This tool runs before submission; a false
BLOCKERis more costly than a missedLOW.
When to read which reference
references/arxiv_policy_notes.md— when calibrating disclosure recommendations or moderation findings.references/ai_artifact_patterns.md— when extending or interpreting the artifact scanner's hits.references/reference_verification.md— when interpreting citation lookup output, deciding API order, or handling rate-limit / network failures.references/report_template.md— when writing or regenerating the final report.
MVP scope
This skill currently ships: text extraction, AI-artifact scan, BibTeX + DOI/arXiv-ID reference verification, extracted label/citation/number structures, and Markdown report generation. Out of scope for v1: full semantic peer review, full claim/result verification, automated moderation judgement, AI-writing probability scoring, automatic rewriting, automated arXiv upload, large-scale plagiarism detection. If the user asks for these, say so explicitly rather than approximating.
相关科研 Skill
中药材分子鉴定用ITS2等DNA条形码鉴定药材基原物种,处理多基原与降解样品局限。适用于药材真伪鉴别研究,不替代法定检验。
中药网络药理学用TCMSP等数据库构建成分-靶点-通路网络并做富集分析,批判性讨论方法学局限。适用于中药机制假设生成与论文方法复核。
中医术语标准与知识图谱建立中医药术语与WHO/ICD-11标准的映射,设计本体并用Neo4j构建知识图谱。适用于数据整合与科研检索,不作临床决策系统。
方剂配伍规律挖掘对方剂做药名规范化、关联规则与网络聚类分析,发现候选核心药组。适用于用药规律挖掘,结果仅为待验证假设,不作处方依据。
证候与症状数据分析对症状量表数据做术语规范、潜在类别与因子分析,探索统计学证候模式。适用于证候分型研究,结果不用于个体辨证诊断。
泵用混合物热力学计算Calculates thermodynamic properties and mixture phase behavior for pump applications using the thermo Python library’s DIPPR/NIST correlations. Use for VLE or mixture property calculations.
常见问题
arXiv 投稿预检能做什么?
arXiv 投稿前的稿件就绪度自检(假参考文献 / 残留 LLM 提示 / 占位数据 / AI 使用披露 / 科研诚信) | 输入:论文文件夹 | 输出:就绪度报告(假参考 / 残留 prompt / 数据占位 / AI 披露)。
如何安装arXiv 投稿预检?
在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「arXiv 投稿预检」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。
arXiv 投稿预检需要哪些权限?
该科研 Skill声明需要:本地文件。安装前会再次列出,由你确认后才会生效。
arXiv 投稿预检经过官方审核吗?
是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。