科研 Skill

报道法律风险审查

media-law-risk-review

Flags defamation, privacy-tort, and prior-restraint risk in a draft before legal review or publication. Use before publishing a sensitive story naming identifiable people.

发布者 Codar安全审核通过v0.1.0更新于 2026-11-18

SKILL.md

Media law risk review

A structured pass over a draft story to flag legal exposure before it goes to a lawyer or to publication. This is not legal advice, it is a triage method that tells a reporter or editor what to bring to counsel and what to fix first.

Purpose

Most defamation and privacy problems in journalism are preventable at the editing stage: an unsupported characterization, a quote taken out of context, a private fact with no public-interest justification, a document used without checking its provenance. This skill walks a draft through the same questions a media lawyer asks first, so the reporter arrives at legal review with the easy problems already fixed and the hard ones already flagged.

When to use

  • Before publishing any story that names a private person in a negative light.
  • Before publishing an accusation of crime, fraud, incompetence, or misconduct against a named person or organization.
  • Before using a leaked or confidential document.
  • Before publishing anything involving a minor, a medical condition, a sexual assault allegation, or someone's immigration status.
  • Before an op-ed or investigative piece goes to outside legal review, to pre-flag the sections most likely to draw questions.

When not to use

  • Routine news writing with no disputed facts about an identifiable person.
  • As a substitute for actual legal review on a high-risk story. This skill prepares the draft for a lawyer; it does not replace one.

Core defamation framework (US)

Defamation is a false statement of fact, published to a third party, that damages someone's reputation. Three questions do most of the triage work:

  1. Is it a statement of fact or opinion? Pure opinion ("I think the mayor is a bad leader") is protected. A factual assertion dressed as opinion ("In my opinion, the mayor took the bribe") is not protected by the opinion label if it implies an undisclosed, verifiable fact.
  2. Is it true? Truth is a complete defense in US defamation law. "Can we prove this in court, not just believe it" is the real bar, substantial truth (the gist is accurate even if a minor detail is off) is usually enough.
  3. What is the subject's status? US law sets a different fault standard by plaintiff type:
    • Public official / public figure: must prove "actual malice", the publisher knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth (New York Times v. Sullivan, 1964). This is a high bar.
    • Private figure on a matter of public concern: most states require only negligence, did the newsroom fail to exercise reasonable care in checking the claim. This is a much lower bar and the single biggest risk multiplier for stories about private individuals.
    • Limited-purpose public figure: someone who became prominent in a specific controversy; actual malice applies but only within that controversy's scope.

Per-claim risk flags

For each potentially defamatory statement in the draft, record:

**Claim:** [exact sentence]
**Subject:** [name] — [public official / public figure / limited-purpose / private]
**Fault standard that applies:** [actual malice / negligence]
**Evidence on file:** [documents, on-record quotes, data]
**Opinion or fact:** [classification + why]
**Risk level:** [low / medium / high]
**Fix needed:** [attribution, hedging language, additional corroboration, none]

High-risk patterns to flag automatically:

  • An accusation of a crime that hasn't resulted in a charge or conviction.
  • A claim sourced to a single anonymous source with no documentary backup.
  • A quote or document whose authenticity hasn't been independently verified (route to the source-verification skill first).
  • A headline or social-media teaser that overstates what the body actually supports — headlines are a common, avoidable source of defamation claims because they're read far more often than the story and get less scrutiny.

Privacy torts (distinct from defamation)

A true statement can still create legal exposure. Four US privacy torts to check, especially for stories involving private individuals:

TortWhat it requiresExample
Public disclosure of private factsTrue, highly offensive, not newsworthy fact disclosedPublishing a named person's HIV status with no public-interest tie
False lightTrue-ish but misleading portrayal that would offend a reasonable personPhoto of a random bystander used to illustrate a story about drug use
Intrusion upon seclusionHow the information was obtained (not what was published)Recording someone through a window, trespassing to get a shot
Appropriation / right of publicityUsing someone's name or likeness for commercial gain without consentUsing a person's photo in a promotional ad for the publication

Newsworthiness is the primary defense for the first two; genuinely private, non-public-interest facts about ordinary people (medical details, sexual history, financial records not tied to a public role) carry the highest risk.

Prior restraint and injunctions

US courts very rarely block publication before it happens (prior restraint faces a heavy presumption of unconstitutionality under Near v. Minnesota, 1931, and New York Times Co. v. United States, 1971 — the Pentagon Papers case). A request or threat to "hold" a story pending legal review is not the same as a court order; distinguish:

  • A subject's lawyer sending a demand letter: not a legal bar to publishing. Document it, give counsel the chance to review, but it doesn't by itself require a hold.
  • An actual temporary restraining order or injunction: this does bar publication; escalate to editor and legal immediately, do not publish while researching whether it's enforceable.

Outside the United States — jurisdiction matters

Defamation law outside the US is often far more claimant-friendly. Flag explicitly when a story will be published, read, or has any nexus (a subject, server, or distributor) in:

  • England and Wales: truth is a defense but the burden of proving it falls on the publisher, not the claimant (reversed from the US); "libel tourism" made the UK a preferred venue for claimants worldwide before the Defamation Act 2013 raised the bar with a "serious harm" threshold, it remains more publisher-unfriendly than the US.
  • EU "right to be forgotten" (Google Spain, 2014) and GDPR: can require removal or delisting of true, lawfully published personal information after the fact, a mechanism that doesn't exist in US law.
  • Jurisdictions with criminal defamation: some countries still criminalize defamation (fines or jail), which changes the risk calculus for a reporter or publication with any presence there.

When a story's facts or subjects cross borders, state which jurisdiction's law applies before relying on the US framework above.

Pre-publication checklist

## Legal risk review: [story title]

- [ ] Every negative factual claim about an identifiable person has
      documented evidentiary support (not just belief).
- [ ] Each subject's status (public official/figure vs. private) is
      identified and the correct fault standard applied.
- [ ] Opinion is clearly framed as opinion; no fact-dressed-as-opinion.
- [ ] Every named subject of a negative claim was offered a chance to
      respond before publication (document date/time/method of outreach
      and response or non-response).
- [ ] Leaked or confidential documents' authenticity and chain of custody
      are verified (see source-verification skill).
- [ ] Private facts about non-public figures have an explicit newsworthiness
      justification on file, not just "it's interesting."
- [ ] Headline and social copy don't claim more than the body supports.
- [ ] Any reporting method that could be intrusion (recording, access to
      private spaces, deception) is logged and justified.
- [ ] Cross-border exposure identified and flagged to legal if applicable.
- [ ] Shield-law / reporter's-privilege posture is known if a source needs
      protecting (varies by state; no federal shield law in the US as of
      2026, reporters rely on state shield statutes and qualified privilege
      case law, which differ significantly by jurisdiction).

Prerequisites

  • This skill performs triage, not legal representation. A lawyer licensed in the relevant jurisdiction must review any story flagged medium or high risk before publication.
  • Requires access to the full reporting record (documents, recordings, source contact notes) to assess whether claims are actually supported, not just the draft text.

Limitations

  • This skill's defamation framework is US-centric (the actual-malice / negligence distinction is a US doctrine). Non-US jurisdictions have materially different rules, do not apply the US risk levels to a story governed by another country's law without adapting the analysis.
  • It cannot assess the credibility or legal sufficiency of evidence on its own, it can only flag where evidence appears thin or missing and route the reporter to fix it or escalate.
  • Law changes; shield-law coverage, right-to-be-forgotten scope, and defamation standards shift by statute and case law. Verify current law in the applicable jurisdiction rather than treating the summaries above as settled for all time.
  • Not a substitute for a publication's actual legal/standards process, where one exists, use this skill to prepare for it, not to bypass it.

Related skills

  • source-verification, Verify the authenticity of documents and claims before they reach the risk review
  • fact-check-workflow, Verify each individual factual claim before assessing its legal risk
  • crisis-communications, Handle the fallout if a legal risk materializes after publication

示例提示词

这篇稿子点名批评了具体人物,帮我做一次发稿前的诽谤和隐私风险审查。

所属插件

新闻传播学面向新闻传播研究与调查报道:事实核查与信源核验、数据新闻、信息公开申请、采访准备与转录、编辑流程与新闻文风、社交媒体情报、图片元数据、网页与数字存档、危机传播。

安装该插件会一并获得同领域的 19 个 Skill / MCP。

同插件的其他科研 Skill

常见问题

报道法律风险审查能做什么?

Flags defamation, privacy-tort, and prior-restraint risk in a draft before legal review or publication. Use before publishing a sensitive story naming identifiable people。

如何安装报道法律风险审查?

在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「报道法律风险审查」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。

报道法律风险审查需要哪些权限?

该科研 Skill没有声明额外权限;执行具体操作时仍由 Agent 按自身规则请求确认。

报道法律风险审查经过官方审核吗?

是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。