科研 Skill

批判话语分析

discourse-analysis

Guides critical and political discourse analysis of texts or media: framing, stance, and power-relation coding with an explicit scheme. Use for interpretive discourse research, not topic modeling.

发布者 Codar安全审核通过v0.1.0更新于 2026-11-18

SKILL.md

Discourse Analysis (Critical / Political Discourse Analysis)

Purpose

Discourse analysis studies how language constructs meaning, identity, and power relations in a text or body of texts — not just what a text says, but how it positions actors, naturalizes some claims while contesting others, and reproduces or resists power relations. This is distinct from thematic coding (what topics appear) and from computational text-as-data methods (frequency, topic models, sentiment scores), which measure surface patterns rather than interpret how meaning is constructed. Use this skill when the research question is about framing, legitimation, stance-taking, identity construction, or ideology in text — speeches, policy documents, news coverage, social media, or institutional communication.

When to Use

Use when the request mentions:

  • critical discourse analysis (CDA), political discourse analysis
  • framing analysis at the level of language choice (not just topic labels)
  • stance, positioning, legitimation/delegitimation strategies
  • how a text constructs identity, authority, or power relations
  • ideology in media or policy language

Do not use for:

  • topic modeling or dictionary-based sentiment (see text-as-data, alterlab-text-as-data, text-analytics-architect)
  • structured thematic coding of interview transcripts aimed at theory-building from participant meaning (see qualitative-thematic-coder, alterlab-qualitative-analysis) — those code what was said; discourse analysis asks how saying it that way does something
  • anthropological framing of policy actor positions specifically (see beebe-policy-framing, which is a related but narrower actor-attributed framing method with its own coding scheme)

Core Workflow

Step 1 — Define the Analytic Question and Select an Approach

State explicitly which discourse-analytic tradition you are using, since each asks a different question and uses different tools:

  • Fairclough's CDA (three-dimensional model): text → discursive practice (production/consumption) → social practice (power, ideology). Best for asking how a text reproduces or challenges social structures.
  • Critical Discourse-Historical Approach (Wodak): adds explicit attention to historical context and a catalogue of legitimation strategies (authorization, rationalization, moral evaluation, mythopoesis). Best for political speech and policy legitimation.
  • van Dijk's socio-cognitive approach: focuses on the "ideological square" — emphasize Us-good/Them-bad, de-emphasize Us-bad/Them-good. Best for in-group/out-group framing in media or political rhetoric.
  • Positioning theory / membership categorization: focuses on how speakers assign rights, duties, and identities to themselves and others in interaction. Best for conversational or interview discourse.

Pick one as the primary lens and say why; mixing frameworks without justification produces an unfocused analysis.

Step 2 — Assemble and Bound the Corpus

Specify the sampling frame (which speeches, which outlets, which date range, which selection criterion) and justify it. Discourse analysis is usually small- to medium-N and intensive rather than exhaustive — state why these texts and not others, and what population of discourse they are meant to represent (or not represent, if the claim is case-specific).

Step 3 — Build a Coding Scheme Before Close Reading

Decide in advance, then revise iteratively, the linguistic and rhetorical features you will code:

  • lexical choice (loaded terms, euphemism, naming/labeling of actors)
  • transitivity and agency (who is the grammatical subject/agent of consequential actions; passive voice that obscures responsibility)
  • modality (certainty markers: "must," "may," "it is clear that")
  • presupposition and implicature (what is assumed true without being stated)
  • intertextuality (quoting, echoing, or contesting other texts/voices)
  • legitimation strategy (per the chosen framework in Step 1)

Document the scheme with definitions and at least one example per category before coding the full corpus — this is the discourse-analytic equivalent of a codebook and is what a reviewer will ask to see.

Step 4 — Close-Read and Code

Work passage by passage. For each coded instance, retain the verbatim quote, its location, and the code(s) applied — never paraphrase the evidence away from the primary text, since the exact wording is the data in this method.

Step 5 — Build the Interpretive Argument

Move from codes to argument: what pattern of framing, legitimation, or positioning recurs across the corpus, and what does it do (whose interests does it serve, what alternative framings does it foreclose)? Ground every interpretive claim in specific quoted evidence; an interpretive claim with no anchoring quote is an assertion, not an analysis.

Step 6 — Address Reflexivity and Trustworthiness

State the analyst's positionality relative to the text/actors, and how alternative readings were considered. Discourse analysis is explicitly interpretive, not "objective" in the quantitative sense — its credibility rests on transparent, well-evidenced reasoning and engagement with alternative readings, not on inter-coder statistical reliability (though a second coder's independent read can still strengthen the claim; report agreement and disagreement qualitatively rather than as a kappa statistic).

Prerequisites

  • A bounded corpus of texts in a language the analyst (or a documented translation process) can read closely; machine translation changes the very linguistic features (modality, lexical choice) this method analyzes, so flag any non-native-language analysis explicitly.
  • Familiarity with the chosen framework (Fairclough, Wodak, van Dijk, or positioning theory) sufficient to apply its specific categories rather than a generic "look for bias" approach.

Limitations

  • This is an interpretive method: findings are an evidenced argument, not a statistically generalizable estimate. Do not report significance tests or frequencies as if they were the basis of the claim — if frequency counts are reported, label them as descriptive context, not as the warrant for the interpretive argument.
  • Does not scale to large corpora the way topic modeling does; for large-N text measurement, pair with text-as-data or alterlab-text-as-data and use discourse analysis on a purposively selected subsample for depth.
  • Translation and transcription choices materially affect discourse-analytic categories (modality, agency); document them rather than treating a translated transcript as equivalent to the original.
  • Generalization beyond the analyzed corpus requires an explicit case-selection or saturation argument, not an implicit assumption of representativeness.

Quality Checklist

  • Analytic framework (Fairclough / Wodak / van Dijk / positioning) named and justified
  • Corpus sampling frame and bounds stated and justified
  • Coding scheme documented with definitions and examples before full coding
  • Every interpretive claim anchored to a verbatim, sourced quote
  • Positionality and alternative readings addressed
  • Scope of generalization stated honestly (this corpus, not all discourse on the topic)

示例提示词

我想对政策演讲做批判话语分析,拆解其框架建构与合法化策略。

所属插件

社会学、政治学与城市研究面向社会科学研究:问卷与访谈设计、质性编码、文本即数据、社会网络、ABM、比较政治与选举数据、RCT 与 DID、城市与区域分析。

安装该插件会一并获得同领域的 58 个 Skill / MCP。

同插件的其他科研 Skill

常见问题

批判话语分析能做什么?

Guides critical and political discourse analysis of texts or media: framing, stance, and power-relation coding with an explicit scheme. Use for interpretive discourse research, not topic modeling。

如何安装批判话语分析?

在科搭 Codar 左侧点击「插件」,在「组件」页签搜索「批判话语分析」并安装;在 Claude Code 或 Codex 中可以发送本页的安装提示词,或下载 Skill 包后解压到 ~/.claude/skills 或 ~/.codex/skills。

批判话语分析需要哪些权限?

该科研 Skill没有声明额外权限;执行具体操作时仍由 Agent 按自身规则请求确认。

批判话语分析经过官方审核吗?

是。SpeedSkills 收录的每个版本都会记录内容摘要与权限声明,当前版本已通过安全审核。